Why Malarkey Shingles Stand Out + Full Comparison Guide
If you live in Oklahoma City, Norman, Moore, or Edmond, your roof isn’t just a part of your home—it’s your first line of defense against hail, wind, and extreme weather.
The biggest mistake homeowners make?
Choosing the wrong shingle.
At TopView Roofing, we specialize in installing impact-resistant shingles, and one brand we strongly recommend is Malarkey shingles—manufactured right here in Oklahoma City.
In this guide, we’ll break down:
- What impact-resistant shingles really are
- Why Malarkey stands out
- How it compares to GAF, Owens Corning, and designer shingles
- How you can save money on insurance
What Are Impact-Resistant Shingles?
Impact-resistant shingles—also called Class 4 shingles—are designed to withstand hail and debris.
They are tested using a steel ball impact test to simulate hail strikes. The highest rating, Class 4, means the shingle can resist severe damage.
👉 Why this matters in Oklahoma:
- Hailstorms are frequent
- Insurance claims are common
- Standard shingles fail faster
Class 4 shingles are engineered to flex instead of crack, often using advanced materials like SBS polymer-modified asphalt
Why We Recommend Malarkey Shingles (Made in Oklahoma City)
Malarkey shingles are not just another roofing product—they’re one of the most advanced systems on the market.
🔥 What Makes Malarkey Different?
- SBS Rubberized Asphalt
Malarkey uses a rubberized asphalt that flexes under impact instead of cracking - Class 4 Impact Resistance
Their Vista® and Legacy® lines carry the highest impact rating available - Built for Extreme Weather
Performs better in hail, heat, and cold cycles than traditional shingles - Stronger Granule Retention
Less wear and tear over time - Eco-Friendly Technology
Uses recycled materials and smog-reducing granules
Malarkey vs Other Impact-Resistant Shingles
Let’s break down how Malarkey compares to other top brands used across Oklahoma.
🆚 Malarkey vs Owens Corning
Owens Corning Duration FLEX®
- Uses fiberglass base with reinforcement strip
- Class 4 impact rating available
- Easier installation with SureNail® strip
BUT…
- Uses traditional oxidized asphalt
- Can become brittle over time in extreme climates
👉 Key Difference:
Malarkey’s rubberized asphalt absorbs impact better, while Owens Corning relies more on reinforcement layers.
🆚 Malarkey vs GAF
GAF Timberline ArmorShield II
- Class 4 impact resistant
- 130 mph wind ratings
- Strong adhesive bonding system
BUT…
- Traditional asphalt construction
- More focused on system integration than material flexibility
👉 Key Difference:
Malarkey offers better long-term flexibility and hail resistance, while GAF offers strong system warranties and variety.
🆚 Malarkey vs CertainTeed (Designer Shingles)
CertainTeed Landmark / Presidential Series
- Thicker, heavier shingles
- Premium aesthetic (designer look)
- High-end curb appeal
BUT…
- More expensive
- Heavier load on roof structure
- Not always SBS modified
👉 Key Difference:
CertainTeed wins on appearance, but Malarkey wins on performance vs cost.
Designer Shingles vs Impact-Resistant Shingles
This is where homeowners get confused.
Designer (Luxury) Shingles:
- Focus on appearance
- Mimic slate or wood shake
- Higher cost
- Moderate durability
Impact-Resistant Shingles:
- Focus on performance
- Built for storms
- Insurance savings
- Longer lifespan
👉 In Oklahoma, performance almost always matters more than appearance.
Insurance Savings with Impact-Resistant Shingles
This is one of the biggest advantages.
Some insurers consider incentives for qualifying impact-resistant roofing. Ask your insurer about the selected product and your policy before counting on any savings.
- Fewer claims
- Less damage
- Lower risk
A Class 4 rating alone does not determine your premium. Eligibility, documentation, exclusions, and any discount amount depend on your insurer and policy.
Compare the upgrade cost with any savings confirmed in writing by your insurer; savings are not guaranteed to pay for the upgrade.
Why Impact-Resistant Shingles Are Perfect for Oklahoma
Living in:
- Oklahoma City
- Norman
- Moore
- Edmond
Means dealing with:
- Large hail
- High winds
- Rapid weather changes
Standard shingles simply don’t last.
Impact-resistant shingles:
✔ Reduce storm damage
✔ Extend roof life
✔ Protect your home better
The Real Cost Comparison
Let’s break it down simply:
Standard Shingles:
- Lower upfront cost
- More repairs
- More insurance claims
Impact-Resistant (Malarkey):
- Slightly higher upfront
- Fewer repairs
- Insurance savings
- Longer lifespan
👉 Long-term: Compare the complete roof system, installation, budget, and product ratings
Installation Matters More Than Brand
Even the best shingle will fail if installed wrong.
At TopView Roofing, we install every roof with:
- Ice & water shield in valleys
- Proper ventilation systems
- Drip edge installation
- Starter strip system
- 6 nails per shingle (not 4)
- High wind installation methods
Why Homeowners Choose Malarkey in Oklahoma
Across Oklahoma City, Norman, Moore, and Edmond, homeowners are choosing Malarkey because:
✔ Made locally in Oklahoma City
✔ Built for severe weather
✔ Better hail resistance
✔ Longer-lasting performance
✔ Eco-friendly materials
And most importantly…
✔ It saves money long-term
When Should You Upgrade?
You should consider impact-resistant shingles if:
- Your roof is over 10–15 years old
- You’ve had multiple repairs
- You’ve had hail damage
- Your insurance premiums are rising
Get a Discount Roofing Estimate Today
At TopView Roofing, we combine:
- Discount pricing
- Premium Malarkey shingles
- Professional installation
👉 Get your instant estimate here:
https://lead.topviewroofing.com/discount_roofing
Final Thoughts
If you’re replacing your roof in Oklahoma, the choice is simple:
- Standard shingles = short-term thinking
- Impact-resistant shingles = long-term protection
And when it comes to performance, durability, and value…
👉 Malarkey shingles are one of the best choices available—especially right here in Oklahoma.
